Skip to main content
Do We Need Laws That Confront Hate Crimes?
Collection StructureFiring Line broadcast records > Episode guide > Do We Need Laws That Confront Hate Crimes?
Item Title Do We Need Laws That Confront Hate Crimes?
Guest Strossen, Nadine
Guest Jeffrey, Terence
Host Buckley, William F., Jr. (1925-2008)
Date CreatedNovember 12, 1998
Description

"After the black American in Texas was mutilated and killed," Mr. Buckley begins, "and the gay student in Wyoming also mutilated and killed, President Clinton asked for increased federal dominion over hate crimes. Is there a need, let alone a philosophical justification, for such a thing, or was Mr. Clinton's call nothing more than what George Will designated as moral pork barrel?" A crackling exchange over the conflicting legal principles. WFB: "John hits this passerby, who's black, and steals his wallet. Now, if he is convicted merely of stealing, he gets five years, let's say. But if he is convicted of hitting him because he's black, he gets ten years. Now why would that one sentiment, i.e., prejudice, be more greatly penalized than the kind of cupidity that brings on mugging and stealing?" NS: "Well, for the same reason that our civil-rights laws have taken acts that are completely lawful in general-- We have a employment-at-will doctrine in this society, which basically means an employer can refuse to hire somebody or can fire somebody for any reason at all, except... [that] you may not refuse to hire, you may not fire, because of these invidious classifications: race, gender ... So, if you take something that is already a crime, it is completely fair and rational for society to say, 'This is a more serious crime, given the problems of discrimination.'"

Language(s)
Country of Origin
Place RecordedNew York City, New York, United States
DimensionsDuration: 30 minutes
FormatMoving Image
Medium television programs
Aspect Ratio
4:3
Color
color
Soundtrack
sound
Hoover IDProgram S1185
Record Number80040.1467
NotesVideo not currently available for purchase.
RightsCopyright held by Stanford University. This copy is provided for educational and research purposes only. No publication, further reproduction, or reuse of copies, beyond fair use, may be made without the express written permission of the Hoover Institution Library & Archives on behalf of Stanford University.
  • Hoover ID: 80040.1467
  • Amazon DVD
  • Amazon Prime & Instant Video
  • Special order a DVD or digital file
  • Video not available. Request program be made available.
  •  Contact us for licensing information.

Feedback Form

Type of feedback
User data
Close