Skip to main content
A Firing Line Debate: Resolved: That Government Should Not Discriminate against Private Schools
Collection StructureFiring Line broadcast records > Episode guide > A Firing Line Debate: Resolved: That Government Should Not Discriminate against Private Schools
Item Title A Firing Line Debate: Resolved: That Government Should Not Discriminate against Private Schools
Guest Buckley, William F., Jr. (1925-2008)
Guest Glasser, Ira
Guest Edley, Christopher F. (1953-)
Guest Mansour, Jimmy
Guest Curry, William E.
Guest Chase, Bob
Guest Smith, Bob
Guest Du Pont, Pierre S.
Host Buckley, William F., Jr. (1925-2008)
Moderator Kinsley, Michael E.
Date CreatedJune 09, 1997
Description

The topic before the house tonight is vouchers. Should parents be able to choose which school their child attends? And if so, should they be assisted with taxpayers' money? A rousing exchange ranging from the bureaucratic inefficiencies of the public schools (WFB: "In Chicago,... 40 per cent of all students attend Catholic schools. How many non-teaching administrative jobs are required to do this? Thirty-six. You would then expect that the public schools would have ... 54. You would be wrong. The public schools in Chicago have 3,300 administrators") to, in Mr. Curry's phrase, the "root causes" of poor schools: "stratification of class and race in this country" ("Show me a school system where all the parents are in the top percentile of income and I'll show you a bunch of kids who, by and large, are on their way to Harvard. Show me a school system whose parents are in the bottom percentile of income, and I'll show you a bunch of kids on their way to jail"). And on through separation of church and state (Mr. Glasser: "Aha! And over 80 per cent of those kids are going to religious schools whose avowed purpose is not to educate those kids, but to propagate their faiths and convert those children"), to whether the private schools are guilty of cream-skimming (Brother Bob: "We've got students that have been expelled from other schools; I've got a student right now with brain damage. I've got students that are ED, LD-we've got everybody, and I'm not sure who else we should be looking for"), to how large a voucher has to be in order to do a poor family any good.

Language(s)
Country of Origin
Place RecordedFt. Worth, Texas, United States
DimensionsDuration: 2 hrs.
FormatText
Medium television programs
Aspect Ratio
4:3
Color
color
Soundtrack
sound
Hoover IDProgram FLS132
Record Number80040.1407
NotesVideo not currently available for purchase.
RightsCopyright held by Stanford University. This copy is provided for educational and research purposes only. No publication, further reproduction, or reuse of copies, beyond fair use, may be made without the express written permission of the Hoover Institution Library & Archives on behalf of Stanford University.
  • Hoover ID: 80040.1407
  • Amazon DVD
  • Amazon Prime & Instant Video
  • Special order a DVD or digital file
  • Video not available. Request program be made available.
  •  Contact us for licensing information.

Feedback Form

Type of feedback
User data
Close