Skip to main content
A Firing Line Debate: Resolved: That Government Is Not the Solution; It Is the Problem
Collection StructureFiring Line broadcast records > Episode guide > A Firing Line Debate: Resolved: That Government Is Not the Solution; It Is the Problem
Item Title A Firing Line Debate: Resolved: That Government Is Not the Solution; It Is the Problem
Guest Buckley, William F., Jr. (1925-2008)
Guest McGovern, George S. (George Stanley) (1922-2012)
Guest Heston, Charlton
Guest Kirkpatrick, Jeane J.
Guest Weaver, Dennis
Guest Hart, Gary (1936-)
Guest Armey, Richard K. (1940-)
Guest Schroeder, Pat
Host Buckley, William F., Jr. (1925-2008)
Moderator Kinsley, Michael E.
Date CreatedSeptember 10, 1990
Description

Broadcast live. Mr. Buckley frames the question by reminding us that government's derelictions range from the murderous to the risible: "If Hitler hadn't had four hundred divisions, he would have been a routine anti-Semite like Gerald L. K. Smith; as much of a menace as a Ku Klux Klan, which we can cope with without the use of the atom bomb.... Do you know why everyone in New York who can do so communicates via messenger or Federal Express or fax? Because messengers and Federal Express and fax machines are not government enterprises like the Post Office." Mr. Weaver replies: "I think it was James Madison that said, 'If men were angels, no government would be necessary.' And since I fail to see any sets of wings in the audience or on the panelists, I really feel that government in some form is absolutely essential." A high-energy exchange that includes solid nuggets of information: e.g., from Rep. Schroeder: "I looked at what they did in Japan [in social-welfare agencies]... They give money to an agency at the beginning of the year to run the agency. At the end of the year, if there is money left over, then half the money is returned to the treasury, half the money is kept within the agency to pay out incentives, get more efficient equipment, or whatever. So for the first time you have taken government incentives and flipped them, so the incentive is to be efficient, not to be inefficient."

Language(s)
Country of Origin
Place RecordedHillsdale, Michigan, United States
DimensionsDuration: 2 hrs.
FormatText
Medium television programs
Aspect Ratio
4:3
Color
color
Soundtrack
sound
Hoover IDProgram FLS109
Record Number80040.1120
NotesVideo not currently available for purchase.
RightsCopyright held by Stanford University. This copy is provided for educational and research purposes only. No publication, further reproduction, or reuse of copies, beyond fair use, may be made without the express written permission of the Hoover Institution Library & Archives on behalf of Stanford University.
  • Hoover ID: 80040.1120
  • Amazon DVD
  • Amazon Prime & Instant Video
  • Special order a DVD or digital file
  • Video not available. Request program be made available.
  •  Contact us for licensing information.

Feedback Form

Type of feedback
User data
Close