Sarah Bachman, San Jose Mercury News moderates.

Roy Beck speaks about the implications of an expanding population on the environment and individual liberties.

Hope Frye speaks about the lack of practical leadership, saying America is repeating history, citing the talking points just before World War II.

Father Tom Shanks speaks about the values the immigration debate brings out. He points out that society is starting to believe compassion and reason are mutually exclusive.

Yeling (sp?) Wing speaks about the implication of immigration on the economy, schools, and social services. She argues the increasing population is harming existing natives, particularly minorities, and previous immigrants.

All the panelists focus on legal immigration.